The Young Child’s Theory of Mind
The Young Child’s Theory of Mind
As representation of the world, memory, and problem solving improve, children start to reflect on their own thought processes. They begin to construct a theory of mind, or coherent set of ideas about mental activities. This understanding is also called metacognition , or “thinking about thought” (the prefix meta-means “beyond” or “higher”). As adults, we have a complex appreciation of our inner mental worlds, which we use to interpret our own and others’ behavior and to improve our performance on various tasks. How early are children aware of their mental lives, and how complete and accurate is their knowledge?
Awareness of Mental Life.
At the end of the first year, babies view people as intentional beings who can share and influence one another’s mental states, a milestone that opens the door to new forms of communicationjoint attention, social referencing, preverbal gestures, and spoken language. These early milestones serve as the foundation for later mental understandings. In longitudinal research, 10-month-olds’ ability to discern others’ intentions predicted theory-of-mind competence at age 4 (Wellman et al., 2008 ). As they approach age 2, children display a clearer grasp of others’ emotions and desires, evident in their realization that people often differ from one another and from themselves in likes, dislikes, wants, needs, and wishes (“Mommy like broccoli. Daddy like carrots. I no like carrots.”). The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
As 2-year-olds’ vocabularies expand, their first verbs include such words as want, think, remember, and pretend (Wellman, 2002 ). By age 3, children realize that thinking takes place inside their heads and that a person can think about something without seeing, touching, or talking about it (Flavell, Green, & Flavell, 1995 ). But 2- to 3-year-olds’ verbal responses indicate that they think that people always behave in ways consistent with their desires and do not understand that less obvious, more interpretive mental states, such as beliefs, also affect behavior.
Between ages 3 and 4, children increasingly refer to their own and others’ thoughts and beliefs (Wellman, 2011 ). And from age 4 on, they say that both beliefs and desires determine behavior. Dramatic evidence for this advance comes from games that test whether preschoolers realize that false beliefsones that do not represent reality accuratelycan guide people’s actions.
TAKE A MOMENT”¦ For example, show a child two small closed boxesa familiar Band-Aid box and a plain, unmarked box (see Figure 7.9 ). Then say, “Pick the box you think has the Band-Aids in it.” Children usually pick the marked container. Next, open the boxes and show the child that, contrary to her own belief, the marked one is empty and the unmarked one contains the Band-Aids. Finally, introduce the child to a hand puppet and explain, “Here’s Pam. She has a cut, see? Where do you think she’ll look for Band-Aids? Why would she look in there? Before you looked inside, did you think that the plain box contained Band-Aids? Why?” (Bartsch & Wellman, 1995 ). Only a handful of 3-year-olds can explain Pam’sand their ownfalse beliefs, but many 4-year-olds can.
Nevertheless, growing evidence indicates that toddlers may have an implicit grasp of false beliefrevealed by their nonverbal behaviors. For example, most 18-month-oldsafter witnessing an object moved from one box to another while an adult was not lookinghelped the adult, when he tried to open the original box, locate the object in the new box (Buttelmann, Carpenter, & Tomasello, 2009 ). And 15- to 18-month-olds’ looking behaviorsin violation-of-expectation studies and in investigations of their anticipatory glances toward the location they expect an adult to reach for an objectyield similar findings (Baillargeon, Scott, & He, 2010 ; Senju et al., 2011 ).
Performance on these implicit false-belief tasks predicts later explicit understanding, evident in the verbal explanations of older preschoolers (San Juan & Astington, 2012 ; Thoermer et al., 2012 ). Still, investigators disagree sharply on the depth of toddlers’ insights. Some argue that they have fully formed representations, others that their awareness is limited. The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Among children of diverse cultural and SES backgrounds, explicit false-belief understanding strengthens after age 3½, becoming more secure between ages 4 and 6 (Amsterlaw & Wellman, 2006 ; Callaghan et al., 2005 ; Flynn, 2006 ). During that time, it becomes a powerful tool for understanding oneself and others and a good predictor of social skills (Harwood & Farrar, 2006 ; Hughes, Ensor, & Marks, 2010 ). It is also associated with early reading ability, probably because it helps children comprehend story narratives (Astington & Pelletier, 2005 ).
FIGURE 7.9 Example of a false-belief task.
(a) An adult shows a child the contents of a Band-Aid box and of an unmarked box. The Band-Aids are in the unmarked container. (b) The adult introduces the child to a hand puppet named Pam and asks the child to predict where Pam would look for the Band-Aids and to explain Pam’s behavior. The task reveals whether children understand that without having seen that the Band-Aids are in the unmarked container, Pam will hold a false belief.
Factors Contributing to Preschoolers’ Theory of Mind.
How do children develop a theory of mind at such a young age? Language, executive function, make-believe play, and social experiences all contribute.
Many studies indicate that language ability strongly predicts preschoolers’ false-belief understanding (Milligan, Astington, & Dack, 2007 ). Children who spontaneously use, or who are trained to use, mental-state words in conversation are especially likely to pass false-belief tasks (Hale & Tager-Flusberg, 2003 ; San Juan & Astington, 2012 ). Among the Quechua people of the Peruvian highlands, whose language lacks mental-state terms, children have difficulty with false-belief tasks for years after children in industrialized nations have mastered them (Vinden, 1996 ). In contrast, Chinese languages have verb markers that can label the word believe as decidedly false. When adults use those markers in false-belief tasks, Chinese preschoolers perform better (Tardif, Wellman, & Cheung, 2004 ). The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Several aspects of preschoolers’ executive functionthe ability to inhibit inappropriate responses, to reason about events inconsistent with immediate reality (for example, how to have avoided walking indoors with muddy shoes), and to planpredict mastery of false belief (Drayton et al., 2011 ; Hughes & Ensor, 2007 ; Müller et al., 2012 ). Gains in inhibition are strongly related to mastery of false belief, perhaps because false-belief tasks require suppression of an irrelevant responsethe tendency to assume that others share their own knowledge and beliefs (Birch & Bloom, 2003 ; Carlson, Moses, & Claxton, 2004 ).
Social experience also promotes understanding of the mind. In longitudinal research, mothers of securely attached babies were more likely to comment appropriately on their infants’ mental states: “Do you remember Grandma?” “You really like that swing!” These mothers continued to describe their children, when they reached preschool age, in terms of mental characteristics: “She’s got a mind of her own!” This maternal “mind-mindedness” was positively associated with later performance on false-belief and other theory-of-mind tasks (Meins et al., 1998 , 2003 ; Ruffman et al., 2006 ). Secure attachment is also related to more elaborative parentchild narratives, including discussions of mental statesconversations that expose preschoolers to concepts and language that help them think about their own and others’ mental lives (Ontai & Thompson, 2008 ; Taumoepeau & Ruffman, 2006 ).
Also, preschoolers with siblings who are children (but not infants)especially older siblings or two or more siblingstend to be more aware of false belief because they are exposed to more family talk about others’ perspectives (Jenkins et al., 2003 ; McAlister & Peterson, 2006 , 2007 ). Similarly, preschool friends who often engage in mental-state talkas children do during make-believe playare ahead in false-belief understanding (de Rosnay & Hughes, 2006 ). Style of adultchild interaction contributes, too. Discourse involving well-connected exchanges in which each speaker’s remark is related to the other’s previous remark predicts preschoolers’ theory-of-mind progress (Ontai & Thompson, 2010). In line with Vygotsky’s theory, these exchanges offer children extra opportunities to talk about inner states, receive feedback, and become increasingly aware of their own and others’ mental activities.
Core knowledge theorists (see Chapter 5 , page 159 ) believe that to profit from the social experiences just described, children must be biologically prepared to develop a theory of mind. They claim that children with autism, for whom mastery of false belief is either greatly delayed or absent, are deficient in the brain mechanism that enables humans to detect mental states. See the Biology and Environment box on the following page to find out more about the biological basis of reasoning about the mind. The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Limitations of Preschoolers’ Understanding of Mental Life.
Though surprisingly advanced, preschoolers’ awareness of mental activities is far from complete. For example, 3- and 4-year-olds are unaware that people continue to think while they wait, look at pictures, listen to stories, or read bookswhen there are no obvious cues that they are thinking (Flavell, Green, & Flavell, 1993 , 1995 , 2000 ). And children younger than age 5 pay little attention to the process of thinking. When asked about subtle distinctions between mental states, such as know and forget, they express confusion (Lyon & Flavell, 1994 ). And they believe that all events must be directly observed to be known. They do not understand that mental inferences can be a source of knowledge (Miller, Hardin, & Montgomery, 2003 ).
These findings suggest that preschoolers view the mind as a passive container of information. As they move into middle childhood, they will increasingly see it as an active, constructive agenta change we will consider further in Chapter 9 .
ORDER NOW FOR AN ORIGINAL PAPER
Early Childhood Literacy
One week, Leslie’s students created a make-believe grocery store. They brought empty food boxes from home, placed them on shelves in the classroom, labeled items with prices, and made paper money for use at the cash register. A sign at the entrance announced the daily specials: “APLS BNS 5¢” (“apples bananas 5¢”).
As such play reveals, preschoolers understand a great deal about written language long before they learn to read or write in conventional ways. This is not surprising: Children in industrialized nations live in a world filled with written symbols. Each day, they observe and participate in activities involving storybooks, calendars, lists, and signs. Children’s active efforts to construct literacy knowledge through informal experiences are called emergent literacy .
Young preschoolers search for units of written language as they “read” memorized versions of stories and recognize familiar signs, such as “PIZZA.” But they do not yet understand the symbolic function of the elements of print (Bialystok & Martin, 2003 ). Many preschoolers think that a single letter stands for a whole word or that each letter in a person’s signature represents a separate name. Children revise these ideas as their cognitive capacities improve, as they encounter writing in many contexts, and as adults help them with written communication. Gradually, they notice more features of written language and depict writing that varies in function, as in the “story” and “grocery list” in Figure 7.10 .
image9
Preschoolers acquire literacy knowledge informally through participating in everyday activities involving written symbols. Here a young chef “jots down” a phone order for a take-out meal.
Biology and Environment “Mindblindness” and Autism
Michael stood at the water table in Leslie’s classroom, repeatedly filling a plastic cup and dumping out its contentsdipsplash, dipsplashuntil Leslie came over and redirected his actions. Without looking at Leslie’s face, Michael moved to a new repetitive pursuit: pouring water from one cup into another and back again. As other children entered the play space and conversed, Michael hardly noticed. The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Michael has autism (a term that means “absorbed in the self”), the most severe behavior disorder of childhood. Like other children with autism, by age 3 he displayed deficits in three core areas of functioning. First, he had only limited ability to engage in nonverbal behaviors required for successful social interaction, such as eye gaze, facial expressions, gestures, imitation, and give-and-take. Second, his language was delayed and stereotyped. He used words to echo what others said and to get things he wanted, not to exchange ideas. Third, he engaged in much less make-believe play than other children (Frith, 2003 ; Walenski, Tager-Flusberg, & Ullman, 2006 ). And Michael showed another typical feature of autism: His interests were narrow and overly intense. For example, one day he sat for more than an hour spinning a toy Ferris wheel.
Researchers agree that autism stems from abnormal brain functioning, usually due to genetic or prenatal environmental causes. Beginning in the first year, children with the disorder have larger-than-average brains, perhaps due to massive overgrowth of synapses and lack of synaptic pruning, which accompanies normal development of cognitive, language, and communication skills (Courchesne, Carper, & Akshoomoff, 2003 ).
Furthermore, the amygdala, devoted to emotion processing (see page 192 in Chapter 6 ), grows especially large in childhood, followed by a greater than average reduction in size in adolescence and adulthood. This deviant growth pattern is believed to contribute to the deficits in emotional responsiveness and social interaction involved in the disorder (Schumann et al., 2009 ; Schumann & Amaral, 2010 ). fMRI studies reveal that autism is also associated with reduced activity in areas of the cerebral cortex involved in processing emotional and social responsiveness and with weaker connections between the amygdala and the temporal lobes (important for processing facial expressions) (Monk et al., 2010 ; Théoret et al., 2005 ).
Mounting evidence reveals that children with autism have a deficient theory of mind. Long after they reach the intellectual level of an average 4-year-old, they have great difficulty with false belief. Most find it hard to attribute mental states to themselves or others (Steele, Joseph, & Tager-Flusberg, 2003 ). They rarely use mental-state words, such as believe, think, know, feel, and pretend. The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
As early as the second year, children with autism show deficits in capacities believed to contribute to an understanding of mental life. Compared with other children, they have difficulty distinguishing facial expressions and less often establish joint attention, engage in social referencing, or imitate an adult’s novel behaviors (Chawarska & Shic, 2009 ; Mundy & Stella, 2000 ; Vivanti et al., 2008 ). Furthermore, they are relatively insensitive to eye gaze as a cue to what a speaker is talking about. Instead, they often assume that another person’s language refers to what they themselves are looking ata possible reason for their frequent nonsensical expressions (Baron-Cohen, Baldwin, & Crowson, 1997 ).
Do these findings indicate that autism is due to impairment in an innate, core brain function, which leaves the child “mindblind” and therefore unable to engage in human sociability? Some researchers think so (Baron-Cohen & Belmonte, 2005 ; Scholl & Leslie, 2000 ). But others point out that individuals with mental retardation but not autism also do poorly on tasks assessing mental understanding (Yirmiya et al., 1998 ). This suggests that some kind of general intellectual impairment may be involved.
One conjecture is that children with autism are impaired in executive function. This leaves them deficient in skills involved in flexible, goal-oriented thinking, including shifting attention to relevant aspects of a situation, inhibiting irrelevant responses, applying strategies to hold information in working memory, and generating plans (Joseph & Tager-Flusberg, 2004 ; Robinson et al., 2009 ).
Another possibility is that children with autism display a peculiar style of information processing, preferring to process the parts of stimuli over patterns and coherent wholes (Happé & Frith, 2006 ). Deficits in thinking flexibly and in holistic processing of stimuli would each interfere with understanding the social world because social interaction requires quick integration of information from various sources and evaluation of alternative possibilities.
It is not clear which of these hypotheses is correct. Some research suggests that impairments in social awareness, flexible thinking, processing coherent wholes, and verbal ability contribute independently to autism (Morgan, Maybery, & Durkin, 2003 ; Pellicano et al., 2006 ). Perhaps several biologically based deficits underlie the tragic social isolation of children like Michael.
image10
This child, who has autism, is barely aware of his teacher and classmates. His “mindblindness” might be due to a basic deficit in social awareness, a general impairment in executive function, or a deficit in holistic processing. The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Eventually, children figure out that letters are parts of words and are linked to sounds in systematic ways, as seen in the invented spellings typical between ages 5 and 7. At first, children rely on sounds in the names of letters, as in “ADE LAFWTS KRMD NTU A LAVATR” (“eighty elephants crammed into a[n] elevator”). Soon they grasp soundletter correspondences and learn that some letters have more than one common sound and that context affects their use (McGee & Richgels, 2012 ).
Literacy development builds on a broad foundation of spoken language and knowledge about the world (Dickinson, Golinkoff, & Hirsh-Pasek, 2010 ). Over time, children’s language and literacy progress facilitate each other. Phonological awareness the ability to reflect on and manipulate the sound structure of spoken language, as indicated by sensitivity to changes in sounds within words, to rhyming, and to incorrect pronunciationis a strong predictor of emergent literacy knowledge (Paris & Paris, 2006 ). When combined with soundletter knowledge, it enables children to isolate speech segments and link them with their written symbols. Vocabulary and grammatical skills are also influential.
The more informal literacy-related experiences young children have, the better their language and emergent literacy development and their later reading skills (Dickinson & McCabe, 2001 ; Speece et al., 2004 ). Pointing out lettersound correspondences and playing languagesound games enhance children’s awareness of the sound structure of language and how it is represented in print (Ehri & Roberts, 2006 ). Interactive reading, in which adults discuss storybook content with preschoolers, promotes many aspects of language and literacy development. And adult-supported writing activities that focus on narrative, such as preparing a letter or a story, also have wide-ranging benefits. Each of these literacy experiences is linked to improved reading achievement in middle childhood (Hood, Conlon, & Andrews, 2008 ; Senechal & LeFevre, 2002 ; Storch & Whitehurst, 2001 ). The Young Child’s Theory of Mind.
Compared to their economically advantaged agemates, preschoolers from low-income families have far fewer home and preschool language and literacy learning opportunitiesa gap that translates into large differences in skills vital for reading readiness at kindergarten entry (see Figure 7.11 ) and into widening disparities in reading achievement during the school years (Hoff, 2013 ; Turnbull et al., 2009 ). When teachers of low-income preschoolers were given a tuition-free college course on effective early childhood literacy instruction, they readily offered many more literacy activities in their classrooms (Dickinson & Sprague, 2001 ). And providing parents with children’s books, along with guidance in how to stimulate literacy learning in preschoolers, greatly enhances literacy activities in the home (High et al., 2000 ; Huebner & Payne, 2010 ).
image11
FIGURE 7.10 A story (a) and a grocery list (b) written by a 4-year-old child.
This child’s writing has many features of real print. It also reveals an awareness of different kinds of written expression.
(From McGee, Lea M.; Richgels, Donald J., Literacy’s Beginnings: Supporting Young Readers and Writers, 4th Ed., © 2004, p. 76. Reprinted and electronically reproduced by permission of Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey.)
image12
FIGURE 7.11 Some kindergarten reading readiness skills by family income.
The gap in emergent literacy development between entering-kindergarten students from low-income and middle-income families is large.
(Adapted from Lee & Burkham, 2002.)
Get a 10 % discount on an order above $ 50
Use the following coupon code :
NURSING10
Order Now
The Young Child’s Theory of Mind
Our Service Charter
1. Professional & Expert Writers: Nurse Papers only hires the best. Our writers are specially selected and recruited, after which they undergo further training to perfect their skills for specialization purposes. Moreover, our writers are holders of masters and Ph.D. degrees. They have impressive academic records, besides being native English speakers.
2. Top Quality Papers: Our customers are always guaranteed of papers that exceed their expectations. All our writers have +5 years of experience. This implies that all papers are written by individuals who are experts in their fields. In addition, the quality team reviews all the papers before sending them to the customers.
3. Plagiarism-Free Papers: All papers provided by Nurse Papers are written from scratch. Appropriate referencing and citation of key information are followed. Plagiarism checkers are used by the Quality assurance team and our editors just to double-check that there are no instances of plagiarism.
4. Timely Delivery: Time wasted is equivalent to a failed dedication and commitment. Nurse Papers is known for timely delivery of any pending customer orders. Customers are well informed of the progress of their papers to ensure they keep track of what the writer is providing before the final draft is sent for grading.
5. Affordable Prices: Our prices are fairly structured to fit in all groups. Any customer willing to place their assignments with us can do so at very affordable prices. In addition, our customers enjoy regular discounts and bonuses.
6. 24/7 Customer Support: At Nurse Papers , we have put in place a team of experts who answer to all customer inquiries promptly. The best part is the ever-availability of the team. Customers can make inquiries anytime.

Recent Comments