Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion
Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion
Piaget’s deemphasis on language as a source of cognitive development brought on yet another challenge, this time from Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, which stresses the social context of cognitive development. During early childhood, rapid growth of language broadens preschoolers’ participation in social dialogues with more knowledgeable individuals, who encourage them to master culturally important tasks. Soon children start to communicate with themselves in much the same way they converse with others. This greatly enhances their thinking and ability to control their own behavior. Let’s see how this happens.
Private Speech
TAKE A MOMENT”¦ Watch preschoolers as they play and explore the environment, and you will see that they frequently talk out loud to themselves. For example, as Sammy worked a puzzle, he said, “Where’s the red piece? Now, a blue one. No, it doesn’t fit. Try it here.”
Piaget ( 1923 / 1926 ) called these utterances egocentric speech, reflecting his belief that young children have difficulty taking the perspectives of others. Their talk, he said, is often “talk for self” in which they express thoughts in whatever form they happen to occur, regardless of whether a listener can understand. Piaget believed that cognitive development and certain social experiences eventually bring an end to egocentric speech. Specifically, through disagreements with peers, children see that others hold viewpoints different from their own. As a result, egocentric speech declines. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
A preschooler explores the possibilities of a handful of soap bubbles with the aid of private speech. Research supports Vygotsky’s theory that children use private speech to guide their thinking and behavior.
Vygotsky ( 1934/1987 ) disagreed with Piaget’s conclusions. Because language helps children think about their mental activities and behavior and select courses of action, Vygotsky saw it as the foundation for all higher cognitive processes, including controlled attention, deliberate memorization and recall, categorization, planning, problem solving, and self-reflection. In Vygotsky’s view, children speak to themselves for self-guidance. As they get older and find tasks easier, their self-directed speech is internalized as silent, inner speechthe internal verbal dialogues we carry on while thinking and acting in everyday situations.
Over the past three decades, almost all studies have supported Vygotsky’s perspective (Berk & Harris, 2003 ; Winsler, 2009 ). As a result, children’s self-directed speech is now called private speech instead of egocentric speech. Research shows that children use more of it when tasks are appropriately challenging (neither too easy nor too hard), after they make errors, or when they are confused about how to proceed. With age, as Vygotsky predicted, private speech goes underground, changing into whispers and silent lip movements. Furthermore, children who freely use private speech during a challenging activity are more attentive and involved and show better task performance than their less talkative agemates (Al-Namlah, Fernyhough, & Meins, 2006 ; Lidstone, Meins, & Fernyhough, 2010 ; Winsler, Naglieri, & Manfra, 2006 ).
Social Origins of Early Childhood Cognition
Where does private speech come from? Recall from Chapter 5 that Vygotsky believed that children’s learning takes place within the zone of proximal developmenta range of tasks too difficult for the child to do alone but possible with the help of adults and more skilled peers. Consider the joint activity of Sammy and his mother as she helps him put together a difficult puzzle:
Sammy:
I can’t get this one in. [Tries to insert a piece in the wrong place.]
Mother:
Which piece might go down here? [Points to the bottom of the puzzle.]
Sammy:
His shoes. [Looks for a piece resembling the clown’s shoes but tries the wrong one.]
Mother:
Well, what piece looks like this shape? [Points again to the bottom of the puzzle.]
Sammy:
The brown one. [Tries it, and it fits; then attempts another piece and looks at his mother.]
Mother:
Try turning it just a little. [Gestures to show him.]
Sammy:
There! [Puts in several more pieces while his mother watches.]
Sammy’s mother keeps the puzzle within his zone of proximal development, at a manageable level of difficulty. To do so, she engages in scaffolding adjusting the support offered during a teaching session to fit the child’s current level of performance. When the child has little notion of how to proceed, the adult uses direct instruction, breaking the task into manageable units, suggesting strategies, and offering rationales for using them. As the child’s competence increases, effective scaffolders gradually and sensitively withdraw support, turning over responsibility to the child. Then children take the language of these dialogues, make it part of their private speech, and use this speech to organize their independent efforts.
What evidence supports Vygotsky’s ideas on the social origins of cognitive development? In several studies, children whose parents were effective scaffolders used more private speech, were more successful when attempting difficult tasks on their own, and were advanced in overall cognitive development (Berk & Spuhl, 1995 ; Conner & Cross, 2003 ; Mulvaney et al., 2006 ). Adult cognitive supportteaching in small steps and offering strategiespredicts gains in children’s thinking. And among Caucasian-American parentchild pairs, adult emotional supportoffering encouragement and allowing the child to take over the taskpredicts children’s effort (Neitzel & Stright, 2003 ).
ORDER NOW FOR AN ORIGINAL PAPER
Nevertheless, effective scaffolding varies among cultures, as an investigation of Hmong families who had emigrated from Southeast Asia to the United States illustrates. Unlike Caucasian-American parents, who emphasize independence by encouraging their children to think of ways to approach a task, Hmong parentswho highly value interdependence and child obediencefrequently tell their children what to do (for example, “Put this piece here, then this piece on top of it”) (Stright, Herr, & Neitzel, 2009 ). Among Caucasian-American children, such directive scaffolding is associated with kindergartners’ lack of self-control and behavior problems. Among Hmong children, however, it predicts greater rule following, organization, and task completion. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
Finally, although children benefit from working on tasks with same-age peers, their planning and problem solving improve more when their partner is either an “expert” peer (especially capable at the task) or an adult. And peer disagreement (emphasized by Piaget) is less important in fostering cognitive development than the extent to which children resolve differences of opinion and cooperate (Kobayashi, 1994 ; Tudge, 1992 ).
Vygotsky and Education
Both Piagetian and Vygotskian classrooms accept individual differences and provide opportunities for children’s active participation. But a Vygotskian classroom goes beyond independent discovery to promote assisted discovery. Teachers guide children’s learning, tailoring their interventions to each child’s zone of proximal development. Assisted discovery is aided by peer collaboration, as children of varying abilities work in groups, teaching and helping one another.
Vygotsky ( 1933 / 1978 ) saw make-believe play as the ideal social context for fostering cognitive development in early childhood. As children create imaginary situations, they learn to follow internal ideas and social rules rather than their immediate impulses. For example, a child pretending to go to sleep follows the rules of bedtime behavior. A child imagining himself as a father and a doll as a child conforms to the rules of parental behavior. According to Vygotsky, make-believe play is a unique, broadly influential zone of proximal development in which children try out a wide variety of challenging activities and acquire many new competencies.
Turn back to page 227 to review findings that make-believe play enhances a diverse array of cognitive and social skills. Pretending is also rich in private speecha finding that supports its role in helping children bring action under the control of thought (Krafft & Berk, 1998 ). And preschoolers who spend more time engaged in sociodramatic play are better at taking personal responsibility for following classroom rules and at regulating emotion (Berk, Mann, & Ogan, 2006 ; Lemche et al., 2003 ). These findings support the role of make-believe in children’s increasing self-control.
In this Vygotsky-inspired classroom, 4- and 5-year-olds benefit from peer collaboration. As they jointly make music, their conductor ensures that each player stays on beat.
Evaluation of Vygotsky’s Theory
In granting social experience a fundamental role in cognitive development, Vygotsky’s theory underscores the vital role of teaching and helps us understand the wide cultural variation in children’s cognitive skills. Nevertheless, it has not gone unchallenged. Verbal communication may not be the only means through which children’s thinking developsor even, in some cultures, the most important means. When Western parents scaffold their young children’s mastery of challenging tasks, their verbal communication resembles the teaching that takes place in school, where their children will spend years preparing for adult life. In cultures that place less emphasis on schooling and literacy, parents often expect children to take greater responsibility for acquiring new skills through keen observation and participation in community activities (Paradise & Rogoff, 2009 ; Rogoff, 2003 ). (See the Cultural Influences box on page 236 ). Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
To account for children’s diverse ways of learning through involvement with others, Barbara Rogoff ( 1998 , 2003 ) suggests the term guided participation , a broader concept than scaffolding. It refers to shared endeavors between more expert and less expert participants, without specifying the precise features of communication. Consequently, it allows for variations across situations and cultures.
Finally, Vygotsky’s theory says little about how basic motor, perceptual, attention, memory, and problem-solving skills, discussed in Chapters 4 and 5 , contribute to socially transmitted higher cognitive processes. For example, his theory does not address how these elementary capacities spark changes in children’s social experiences, from which more advanced cognition springs (Miller, 2009 ; Moll, 1994 ). Piaget paid far more attention than Vygotsky to the development of basic cognitive processes. It is intriguing to speculate about the broader theory that might exist today if Piaget and Vygotskythe two twentieth-century giants of cognitive developmenthad had a chance to meet and weave together their extraordinary accomplishments.
ASK YOURSELF
REVIEW Describe features of social interaction that support children’s cognitive development. How does such interaction create a zone of proximal development?
CONNECT Explain how Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s theories complement each other. How would classroom practices inspired by these theories be similar? How would they be different?
APPLY Tanisha sees her 5-year-old son, Toby, talking aloud to himself as he plays. She wonders whether she should discourage this behavior. Use Vygotsky’s theory to explain why Toby talks to himself. How would you advise Tanisha?
REFLECT When do you use private speech? Does it serve a self-guiding function for you, as it does for children? Explain.
Cultural Influences Children in Village and Tribal Cultures Observe and Participate in Adult Work
In Western societies, the role of equipping children with the skills they need to become competent workers is assigned to school. In early childhood, middle-SES parents’ interactions with children emphasize child-focused activities designed to prepare children to succeed in schoolespecially adultchild conversations and play that enhance language, literacy, and other academic knowledge. In village and tribal cultures, children receive little or no schooling, spend their days in contact with adult work, and start to assume mature responsibilities in early childhood (Rogoff et al., 2003 ). Consequently, parents have little need to rely on conversation and play to teach children. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
A study comparing 2- and 3-year-olds’ daily lives in four culturestwo U.S. middle-SES suburbs, the Efe hunters and gatherers of the Republic of Congo, and a Mayan agricultural town in Guatemaladocumented these differences (Morelli, Rogoff, & Angelillo, 2003 ). In the U.S. communities, young children had little access to adult work and spent much time conversing and playing with adults. In contrast, the Efe and Mayan children rarely engaged in these child-focused activities. They spent their days close toand frequently observingadult work, which often took place in or near the Efe campsite or the Mayan family home.
An ethnography of a remote Mayan village in Yucatán, Mexico, shows that when young children are legitimate onlookers and participants in a daily life structured around adult work, their competencies differ from those of Western preschoolers (Gaskins, 1999 ; Gaskins, Haight, & Lancy, 2007 ). Yucatec Mayan adults are subsistence farmers. Men tend cornfields, aided by sons age 8 and older. Women prepare meals, wash clothes, and care for the livestock and garden, assisted by daughters and by sons too young to work in the fields. Children join in these activities from the second year on. When not participating, they are expected to be self-sufficient. Young children make many nonwork decisions for themselveshow much to sleep and eat, what to wear, and even when to start school. As a result, Yucatec Mayan preschoolers are highly competent at self-care. In contrast, their make-believe play is limited; when it occurs, they usually imitate adult work. Otherwise, they watch othersfor hours each day.
Yucatec Mayan parents rarely converse or play with preschoolers or scaffold their learning. Rather, when children imitate adult tasks, parents conclude that they are ready for more responsibility. Then they assign chores, selecting tasks the child can do with little help so that adult work is not disturbed. If a child cannot do a task, the adult takes over and the child observes, reengaging when able to contribute.
Expected to be autonomous and helpful, Yucatec Mayan children seldom ask others for something interesting to do. From an early age, they can sit quietly for long periodsthrough a lengthy religious service or a three-hour truck ride to town. And when an adult directs them to do a chore, they respond eagerly to the type of command that Western children frequently avoid or resent. By age 5, Yucatec Mayan children spontaneously take responsibility for tasks beyond those assigned. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
A Mayan 3-year-old imitates her mother in balancing a basket of laundry on her head. Children in Guatemalan Mayan culture observe and participate in the work of their community from an early age.
image8 Information Processing
Return to the model of information processing discussed on page 161 in Chapter 5 . Recall that information processing focuses on cognitive operations and mental strategies that children use to transform stimuli flowing into their mental systems. As we have already seen, early childhood is a period of dramatic strides in mental representation. And the various components of executive function that enable children to succeed in cognitively challenging situationsincluding attention, impulse control, coordinating information in memory, and planningshow impressive gains (Welsh, Friedman, & Spieker, 2008 ). Preschoolers also become more aware of their own mental life and begin to acquire academically relevant knowledge important for school success. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
Attention
As parents and teachers know, preschoolerscompared with school-age childrenspend shorter times involved in tasks and are easily distracted. But recall from Chapter 5 that sustained attention improves in toddlerhood, a trend that continues during early childhood.
Inhibition.
A major reason is a steady gain in children’s ability to inhibit impulses and keep their mind on a competing goal. Consider a task in which the child must tap once when the adult taps twice and tap twice when the adult taps once or must say “night” to a picture of the sun and “day” to a picture of the moon with stars. As Figure 7.8 shows, 3- and 4-year-olds make many errors. But by age 6 to 7, children find such tasks easy (Johnson, Im-Bolter, & Pascual-Leone, 2003 ; Kirkham, Cruess, & Diamond, 2003 ). They can resist the “pull” of their attention toward a dominant stimulusa skill that, as early as age 3 to 5, predicts social maturity as well as reading and math achievement from kindergarten through high school (Blair & Razza, 2007 ; Duncan et al., 2007 ; Rhoades, Greenberg, & Domitrovich, 2009 ).
Gains in inhibition are linked to development of the cerebral cortex, especially the prefrontal cortex (see page 217 ). But relevant experiences are also crucial. In Tools of the Minda preschool curriculum inspired by Vygotsky’s theoryscaffolding of attention skills is woven into virtually all classroom activities. For example, teachers provide external aids to support attention (a child might hold a drawing of an ear as a reminder to listen during story time); lead games requiring frequent inhibition and memory for instructions; and encourage make-believe play, which helps children follow rules and use thought to guide behavior (Bodrova & Leong, 2007 ). When preschoolers from low-income families were randomly assigned to either Tools of the Mind or comparison classrooms, Tools children performed substantially better on end-of-year tasks assessing inhibition and other attentional capacities (Diamond et al., 2007 ).
FIGURE 7.8 Gains between ages 3 and 7 in performance on tasks requiring children to inhibit an impulse and focus on a competing goal.
In the tapping task, children had to tap once when the adult tapped twice and tap twice when the adult tapped once. In the daynight task, children had to say “night” to a picture of the sun and “day” to a picture of the moon with stars.
(From A. Diamond, 2004, “Normal Development of Prefrontal Cortex from Birth to Young Adulthood: Cognitive Functions, Anatomy, and Biochemistry,” as appeared in D. T. Stuss & R. T. Knight, [Eds.], Principles of Frontal Lobe Function, New York: Oxford University Press, p. 474. Reprinted by permission of Adele Diamond.)
Planning.
By the end of early childhood, children become better at planningthinking out a sequence of acts ahead of time and allocating attention accordingly to reach a goal. As long as tasks are not too complex, 5-year-olds can generate and follow a plan, such as deciding in which of two locations to store a camera so an agemate, who wants to take a photo of a kangaroo, can retrieve the camera before arriving at the kangaroo’s cage (McColgan & McCormack, 2008 ). Although younger children have trouble reasoning about a sequence of future events they have never before experienced, 4-year-olds can reason effectively about a short sequence of past events. For example, on a path with several landmarks they just traveled, they can identify the likely location of lost object (Friedman & Scholnick, 1997 ; Kaller et al., 2008 ).
Children learn much from cultural tools that support planningdirections for playing games, patterns for construction, recipes for cookingespecially when they collaborate with more expert planners. When 4- to 7-year-olds were observed jointly constructing a toy with their mothers, the mothers provided basic information about the usefulness of plans and how to implement specific steps: “Do you want to look at the picture and see what goes where? What piece do you need first?” After working with their mothers, younger children more often referred to the plan when building on their own (Gauvain, 2004 ; Gauvain, de la Ossa, & Hurtado-Ortiz, 2001 ). When parents encourage planning in everyday activities, from loading the dishwasher to packing for a vacation, they help children plan more effectively. Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
Memory
Unlike infants and toddlers, preschoolers have the language skills to describe what they remember, and they can follow directions on memory tasks. As a result, memory becomes easier to study in early childhood.
Recognition and Recall.
TAKE A MOMENT”¦ Show a young child a set of 10 pictures or toys. Then mix them up with some unfamiliar items, and ask the child to point to the ones in the original set. You will find that preschoolers’ recognition memoryability to tell whether a stimulus is the same as or similar to one they have seen beforeis remarkably good. In fact, 4- and 5-year-olds perform nearly perfectly.
Now keep the items out of view, and ask the child to name the ones she saw. This more challenging task requires recallthat the child generate a mental image of an absent stimulus. Young children’s recall is much poorer than their recognition. At age 2, they can recall no more than one or two of the items, at age 4 only about three or four (Perlmutter, 1984 ).
Improvement in recall in early childhood is strongly associated with language development, which greatly enhances long-lasting representations of past experiences (Melby-Lervag & Hulme, 2010 ; Ornstein, Haden, & Elischberger, 2006 ). But even preschoolers with good language skills recall poorly because they are not skilled at using memory strategies deliberate mental activities that improve our chances of remembering. Preschoolers do not yet rehearse, or repeat items over and over to remember. Nor do they organize, grouping together items that are alike (all the animals together, all the vehicles together) so they can easily retrieve them by thinking of their similar characteristicseven when they are trained to do so (Gathercole, Adams, & Hitch, 1994 ).
Why do young children seldom use memory strategies? One reason is that strategies tax their limited working memories (see page 161 in Chapter 5 ). Preschoolers have difficulty holding on to pieces of information and applying a strategy at the same time.
Memory for Everyday Experiences.
Think about the difference between your recall of listlike information and your memory for everyday experienceswhat researchers call episodic memory . In remembering lists, you recall isolated bits, reproducing them exactly as you originally learned them. In remembering everyday experiences, you recall complex, meaningful information. Between 3 and 6 years, children improve sharply in memory for relations among stimulifor example, in a set of photos, remembering not only the animals they saw but their contexts, such as a bear emerging from a tunnel or a zebra tied to a tree (Lloyd, Doydum, & Newcombe, 2009 ). The capacity to bind together stimuli supports an increasingly rich episodic memory in early childhood.
Memory for Familiar Events.
Like adults, preschoolers remember familiar, repeated eventswhat you do when you go to preschool or have dinnerin terms of scripts , general descriptions of what occurs and when it occurs in a particular situation. Young children’s scripts begin as a structure of main acts. For example, when asked to tell what happens at a restaurant, a 3-year-old might say, “You go in, get the food, eat, and then pay.” Although first scripts contain only a few acts, they are almost always recalled in correct sequence (Bauer, 2002 , 2006 ). With age, scripts become more elaborate, as in this 5-year-old’s account of going to a restaurant: “You go in. You can sit in a booth or at a table. Then you tell the waitress what you want. You eat. If you want dessert, you can have some. Then you pay and go home” (Hudson, Fivush, & Kuebli, 1992 ). Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion.
Scripts help children (and adults) organize and interpret everyday experiences. Once formed, they can be used to predict what will happen in the future. Children rely on scripts in make-believe play and when listening to and telling stories. Scripts also support children’s earliest efforts at planning as they represent sequences of actions that lead to desired goals (Hudson & Mayhew, 2009 ).
Memory for One-Time Events.
In Chapter 5 , we considered a second type of everyday memoryautobiographical memory, or representations of personally meaningful, one-time events. As preschoolers’ cognitive and conversational skills improve, their descriptions of special events become better organized in time, more detailed, and related to the larger context of their lives (Fivush, 2001 ).
Adults use two styles to elicit children’s autobiographical narratives. In the elaborative style, they follow the child’s lead, ask varied questions, add information to the child’s statements, and volunteer their own recollections and evaluations of events. For example, after a trip to the zoo, the parent might say, “What was the first thing we did? Why weren’t the parrots in their cages? I thought the lion was scary. What did you think?” In contrast, adults who use the repetitive style provide little information and keep repeating the same questions regardless of the child’s interest: “Do you remember the zoo? What did we do at the zoo?” Preschoolers who experience the elaborative style recall more information about past events, and they also produce more organized and detailed personal stories when followed up one to two years later (Cleveland & Reese, 2005 ; Farrant & Reese, 2000 ).
As children talk with adults about the past, they not only improve their autobiographical memory but also create a shared history that strengthens close relationships and self-understanding. Parents and preschoolers with secure attachment bonds engage in more elaborate reminiscing (Bost et al., 2006 ; Fivush & Reese, 2002 ). And 5- and 6-year-olds of elaborative-style parents describe themselves in clearer, more consistent ways (Bird & Reese, 2006 ).
Girls produce more organized and detailed narratives than boys. Compared with Asian children, Western children produce narratives with more talk about their own thoughts, emotions, and preferences. These differences fit with variations in parentchild conversations. Parents reminisce in greater detail and talk more about the emotional significance of events with daughters (Fivush, 2009 ). And collectivist cultural valuing of interdependence leads many Asian parents to discourage children from talking about themselves. Chinese parents, for example, engage in less detailed and evaluative past-event dialogues with their preschoolers (Fivush & Wang, 2005 ; Wang, 2006a ).
Consistent with these early experiences, women report an earlier age of first memory and more vivid early memories than men. And Western children and adults’ autobiographical memories include earlier, more detailed events that focus more on their own roles than do the memories of Asians, who tend to highlight the roles of others (Wang, 2006b , 2008 ).
As this toddler talks with his mother about past experiences, she responds in an elaborative style, asking varied questions and contributing her own recollections. Through such conversations, she enriches his autobiographical memory.
Get a 10 % discount on an order above $ 50
Use the following coupon code :
NURSING10
Order Now
Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Discussion
Our Service Charter
1. Professional & Expert Writers: Nurse Papers only hires the best. Our writers are specially selected and recruited, after which they undergo further training to perfect their skills for specialization purposes. Moreover, our writers are holders of masters and Ph.D. degrees. They have impressive academic records, besides being native English speakers.
2. Top Quality Papers: Our customers are always guaranteed of papers that exceed their expectations. All our writers have +5 years of experience. This implies that all papers are written by individuals who are experts in their fields. In addition, the quality team reviews all the papers before sending them to the customers.
3. Plagiarism-Free Papers: All papers provided by Nurse Papers are written from scratch. Appropriate referencing and citation of key information are followed. Plagiarism checkers are used by the Quality assurance team and our editors just to double-check that there are no instances of plagiarism.
4. Timely Delivery: Time wasted is equivalent to a failed dedication and commitment. Nurse Papers is known for timely delivery of any pending customer orders. Customers are well informed of the progress of their papers to ensure they keep track of what the writer is providing before the final draft is sent for grading.
5. Affordable Prices: Our prices are fairly structured to fit in all groups. Any customer willing to place their assignments with us can do so at very affordable prices. In addition, our customers enjoy regular discounts and bonuses.
6. 24/7 Customer Support: At Nurse Papers , we have put in place a team of experts who answer to all customer inquiries promptly. The best part is the ever-availability of the team. Customers can make inquiries anytime.

Recent Comments